Before I was trained in EMDR, I could get most clients most of the way there through talk therapy alone. Somewhere around ninety percent of the way, real insight, real change in how they understood what happened to them. But there was almost always a last stretch, that final ten percent, that talk therapy alone couldn’t touch. People would tell me they understood everything now, and still flinch at the same memory, still feel it in their body exactly the way they always had.
That’s the gap EMDR actually closes.
EMDR stands for Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing, and the comparison I use most often to explain what it actually does is this. An orthopedist sets a broken bone. He doesn’t heal it, and he can’t make it heal faster than the body is built to. What he does is put the bone back into the position where the body’s own healing process can take over. EMDR works the same way with a stuck memory. It doesn’t do the healing itself. It recreates something close to the state your brain enters during REM sleep, which is when your brain naturally processes and files away the day’s experiences, and it uses that same mechanism to set up the conditions where your brain can finally do the healing work it was already built to do, just on a memory that got stuck instead of processed.
That’s why insight alone so often isn’t enough. Understanding a memory and processing a memory are two different things, done by two different systems. You can have the first fully in place and still be missing the second.
I’ve watched this play out the same way for years now, in single incidents like an accident or an assault, but also in longer running things, a difficult childhood, a betrayal, an antisemitic incident that keeps replaying itself, grief that got stuck instead of moving. Some people feel a real shift within a few sessions. Others need more time, especially when there’s more than one memory doing the same thing.
If you’ve already done the work of understanding your story, and you’re still stuck feeling it exactly the way you always have, that last stretch is usually what EMDR is for.
Comments +